The student news site of Mill Valley High School

Mill Valley News

The student news site of Mill Valley High School

Mill Valley News

The student news site of Mill Valley High School

Mill Valley News

WHAT DO YOU THINK?
Sorry, there are no polls available at the moment.
Leading the crowd, seniors Lucy Roy and Ellie Walker waive their flashlights in the air.
Student Council's Open Mic Night gives students the opportunity to show off talents
Evan LeRoy, JagWire reporter/photographer • 21 hours ago
Looking at their papers, sophomores Tristyn Jones and Lillian Gibson laugh at a part of their script at forensics practice Wednesday, Feb. 22.
Forensics team travels to Shawnee Mission East for their second tournament of the season
Barron Fox, JagWire reporter/photographer • February 27, 2024
Smiling, juniors Lily Folendore and Autumn Graves help wash paint brushes alongside De Soto freshman Taryn Round.
Juniors Autumn Graves and Kennedy Goertz spend two Saturdays volunteering at an elementary school clay camp
Emma Clement, JagWire editor-in-chief, Mill Valley News editor-in-chief • February 27, 2024
A tiny robot sits on the Computer Engineering table, demonstrating the wonders of computer engineering to several keen-eyed students.
SWE takes part in the annual Introduce a Girl to Engineering Day
Ian Chern, JagWire copy editor • February 26, 2024

Opinion: Two JagWire reporters go head-to-head in their views on cheating

JagWire reporter Madelyn Mulryan and JagWire editor-in-chief Emma Clement share their opposing opinions
Opinion%3A+Two+JagWire+reporters+go+head-to-head+in+their+views+on+cheating
By Quin Peters

School is changing, and so should cheating’s definition

By Madelyn Mulryan

With artificial intelligence (AI) on the rise, the question of what qualifies as cheating is being frequently debated. I believe that using certain types of resources has been widely misconstrued as ‘cheating.’

One such resource is using AI on schoolwork, which when implemented properly, can simply be a really helpful tool to assist with homework. But it has a reputation of being used to get out of having to do your own work.

AI can be helpful with writing outlines, helping you get started on projects, and it’s really good at helping you study. Using AI can be a really helpful tool if it’s purpose is not just doing your assignments for you.

A more popular debated resource is using Google and other online tools to help with work. If you’re only doing homework, and not a test, looking up and finding answers is not cheating.

In the real world, everyone will be using online resources to help them figure out how to best solve their problems. Being able to correctly research and find answers is a very important real-world skill that people actually need.

Not only is researching a good skill that isn’t recognized, but not everyone in school has the same set of talents.

Those who say you can just study a couple hours to completely learn a topic are privileged. Some people aren’t able to process certain topics as well as others, so they need to use helpful tools such as Google or AI.

Imagine being talented at something that isn’t taught in school, such as building or being persuasive. Both of those talents can introduce you to amazing careers in the future, even though they aren’t popularized in most schools.

Those who have more niche talents like these might not be good at traditional academics like math or science. Why should they fail these classes that they don’t understand and won’t use in the future? All students deserve to have the same opportunities as others, and getting help from online resources allows that.

‘Cheating’ needs to be redefined to make clear that some students are just using their resources to get help.

 

Cheating should not replace the learning opportunity of hard work

By Emma Clement

Almost every student has thought about cheating – had a moment of consideration where they tried to convince themself it was a good idea. Thoughts of, “I just need to pass this class” and “everybody does so why can’t I?” can seem overpowering, but in reality, cheating is never worth it. Putting in the hard work to learn the content will only benefit students.

A study done by the International Center for Academic Inquiry revealed that 95% of high schoolers admitted to cheating in some capacity. Additionally, 64% of students admitted to plagiarism and 58% said they had cheated on a test.

This study shows that cheating is not only common, but frequent in school. However that doesn’t mean it should be. The same study concluded that one of the main reasons students cheated was because they felt pressured to get good grades and do well, especially for overachievers.

While their reasons are valid, cheating is not the only way to success. Though it may feel like an easy solution to being overworked, burnt out or  stressed, it really only makes things worse in the long-term. Cheating takes away opportunities for students to learn how to work hard, prioritize and manage their time.

Facing difficult situations with scheduling and feeling overwhelmed is something anyone can empathize with, but those who use those situations to hone critical thinking and decision making skills are the true successful students and that means that they have to do the work..

Besides being a detriment to the student’s own learning, cheating is also unfair to those students that do put in the effort to get their grades. As many high achievers are aware, academics are a competition: GPA, scholarships and college applications, to name a few. It is unfair for students who cheat to take the easy way out and get ahead of those who are genuinely putting in the effort to succeed.

Cheating to get a good grade in a class may give a brief GPA boost, but the skills gained from problem solving and learning to be imperfect will always be more valuable in the long run.

(Visited 154 times, 1 visits today)
Leave a Comment
More to Discover
About the Contributors
Emma Clement, JagWire editor-in-chief, Mill Valley News editor-in-chief
This is senior Emma Clement’s third year on the JagWire staff. This year she is JagWire and Mill Valley News editor-in-chief, in addition to being a writer and designer for the newspaper. When she is not working on journalism, Emma enjoys reading, drawing, painting, watching TV shows and spending time with friends and family. She is also involved at Mill Valley as NHS president, Spanish NHS vice president, Youth for Refugees president, Model UN president, NAHS vice president and is a member of NEHS, Scholar’s Bowl and Women’s Empowerment Club. Outside of school, Emma works at Pinnacle Gymnastics as a gymnastics coach and is on the editorial board for elementia, the Johnson County Library’s teen literary magazine.
Madelyn Mulryan, JagWire reporter/photographer
This is sophomore Madelyn Mulryan’s first year on the JagWire staff. She is exploring all roles for newspaper but especially writing. She enjoys reading, listening to music, spending quality time with friends and binge-watching shows. Maddie is involved in Youth for Refugees, Women’s Empowerment, Model UN and Debate. She is excited to make this year of newspaper great!
Quin Peters, JagWire reporter/photographer
This is sophomore Quin Peters’ first year on the JagWire staff. She will be exploring the roles of writer and designer for the newspaper this year. Outside of school, Quin crochets, reads, writes creatively and is involved in art. Quin is a member of several clubs at the school, including National Art Honor Society, Youth for Refugees, Women’s Empowerment, Scholars Bowl, Creative Writing Club and Model UN.

Comments (0)

Mill Valley News intends for this area to be used to foster healthy, thought-provoking discussion. Comments are expected to adhere to our standards and to be respectful and constructive. As such, we do not permit the use of profanity, foul language, personal attacks, or the use of language that might be interpreted as libelous. Comments are reviewed and must be approved by a moderator to ensure that they meet these standards. Mill Valley News does not allow anonymous comments, and Mill Valley News requires a valid email address. The email address will not be displayed but will be used to confirm your comments.
All Mill Valley News Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *